Guide

Why did my star rating drop?

Five causes, how to tell which one applies to your product, and the fix for each.

In shortA star rating usually drops for one of five reasons: a product or batch problem, a packaging or delivery problem, a product page that promises more than the product delivers, a new audience the product was not made for, or one variant pulling the others down. Your most recent reviews show which one it is.

First, check that the drop is real

On a product with few reviews, one or two low ratings are enough to move the average. Amazon also explains that its star rating is not a simple average: it takes into account factors such as how recent a rating is and whether it comes from a verified purchase. Compare the reviews of the last 30 to 90 days with the period before, and look at what the low ratings say.

The five causes

  1. A product or batch problem. The same complaint appears from a given date: a texture, a taste, a part that breaks. Fix: check the batch with your supplier and reply to the shoppers concerned.
  2. Packaging or delivery. Reviews say the product arrived damaged, leaking or open, often on one sales channel. Fix: change the packaging or raise it with the carrier or the fulfilment service.
  3. A page that promises too much. Reviews say "not what I expected", "smaller than in the picture" or "does not do what it says". Fix: rewrite the page, the images and the size information so they match the product.
  4. A new audience. A promotion, an advertising campaign or a new market brings buyers the product was not made for. Fix: say clearly on the page who the product is for, and review the targeting.
  5. One variant pulling the others down. Variants often share one rating. One size, shade or flavour collects the complaints. Fix: find the variant and treat it as its own product problem.

What to do this week

  1. Group the low ratings of the last 90 days by topic. One topic usually stands out.
  2. Find the date the topic started. Match it with a batch, a packaging change, a page change or a campaign.
  3. Fix the cause and reply to the shoppers. Where the site allows a public reply, say what has been changed.
  4. Measure again a month later. The topic should fall before the rating recovers.

Where Purples fits

Purples is a consumer intelligence platform for beauty, food and beverage, and fashion brands. It groups your complaints into topics with the count and the period, watches review velocity, and can raise an alarm when low ratings arrive in a burst. The replies to shoppers, the product page update and the note for your supplier are drafted, and each one waits for your approval.

Questions, answered straight

Related questions.

How long does a star rating take to recover?

It depends on how many new ratings the product receives. The rating moves as new ratings come in, so a product with many reviews recovers more slowly than one with few.

Can I have negative reviews removed?

Only reviews that break the rules of the site can be reported to it. The lasting fix is to solve the cause and reply to the shoppers.

Does this apply outside Amazon?

Yes. The five causes are the same on retailer sites and on your own store. Only the way the rating is calculated differs from one site to another.

See this on your own products.

Book a 30-minute demo. A person replies within 48 hours.

Book a demo